Quest for the Sidequest!

You've barely arrived at the abandoned house where you recollect the infield stash may be concealed. The windows are broken, the stairs are falling isolated, and the thousand is a sea of knee-high grass. You walk adequate the front man door, but you can't open it because thither's a strip of yellow police taping crosswise the door with the words DO NOT CROSS transcribed on information technology. Drat! How fundament you set out in? Suddenly a wandering hobo gets your attention. Atomic number 2 tells you that on that point's a crack den just low-spirited the street filled with bloodthirsty, intemperately-armed gangsters. The bu is pretty predestinate they have a span of scissors in the basement that you could use to edit the police mag tape.

I pass on that the person who goes into the crack den for the scissors hold is the second stupidest person in history. The stupidest person in history is the one who came up with this quest in the first grade. I've played more than my share of pursuit / chance / RPG games in my day, and I've seen this request in one form or another about eternity times. It is good agone the point where game designers need to quit doing this.

The almost recent example – and the unitary that brought whol of this to mind – was in Borderlands. Borderlands is an absolute blast, only one quest provoked me like a corky scabies with its lazy key-fetch quest. At combined full stop, you need to get past a rusty eight-foot fence with holes in information technology large enough for most of the characters in the game to plainly crawl through and through. (With the exception of Brick, who ought to be able to rip it thrown surgery leap over.) But, instead, the bet on has you fight direct waves of animals, more waves of insane bandits, then through a hideout of even Sir Thomas More bandits, then fight a fifteen foot berserk cannibal to get the key to open the fence. (And then turn back through every last of those to begin with bad guys, who stimulate respawned.)

It's not that I mind fighting all those guys. In fact, that's what the game is all about. It's right that the justification for doing so is absurd. Like fighting waves of gangsters to get scissors to cut mag tape on a door, it's just way also much fuss and IT doesn't make any sense for my character to fare those things. This is what the story is for: To give purpose and structure to the things the player is doing. If the tarradiddle can't offer you a healthy grounds for doing the stuff you'atomic number 75 doing, then it might arsenic well non exist. Merely preserve the money you're spending connected writers and voice actors if you'Re just exit to send the role player bent vote out stuff for no reason.

(And retributory to glucinium clear: When I articulate "primal" I mean everything that game designers use in a key-like fashion. This includes access code codes, bait, batteries, blowtorches, bribes, buttons, electric circuit boards, cranks, crests, crowbars, datapads, disguises, explosives, fuses, gas masks, gears, gems, lubricating oil, hammers, hazmat suits, identify cards, levers, lights / lightbulbs, passwords, puzzles, robots, screwdrivers, sigils, spells, switches, wire cutters, wrenches, and rubber chickens with a pulley midmost.)

* In Neverwinter Nights 2, you spend roughly one-quarter of the entire game doing sub-sub-hero quests to open a single metropolis gate so you can talk to somebody on the other incline of information technology. This doorway annoyed me much I elaborated the quest here.

* In Champions Online,my hulky superhero had to quest to begin a key to open a awkward outhouse. A violent outhouse.

* In Resident Evil 4, the protagonists encounter a hilariously flimsy gate constructed across the path in the woods. Instead of walk around it, mounting over IT, burning it go through, or toppling it with a shove, Leon decides the lonesome possible road to freedom is to take the president's daughter direct the heart of the enemy base and into the 9th ring of hell.

* Virtually the entire plot electric arc of Fable 2.

In comprehensive, I think the motion game designers should ask themselves is: Is the thing you're asking the player character to do the most obvious, straightforward, or fastest way to solve the minded problem? Interrogatory the player to go downstairs and set about a paint for a shoddy wooden threshold is not unreasonable. I certainly wouldn't bankrupt a door if the key was just downstairs. Asking the player to climb to the top of Mt. Infernal and fight the Person-Devouring Dragon-Wraith of Pest to get the Same key is completely ludicrous, because at that point it's less cark to just kick the door down OR call a locksmith operating theatre something. (Exclusion: All comedy games bring fort a free pass around for plot doors because the stupidity of the English-quest is part of the joke.)

The obstacle in need of a key should be at least as formidable as the thing the player has to do to get the key. I have it off these aren't sandbox games and we possess to be on rails to a certain extent. All I'm asking is that the track draw some kind of sense. Most of this plat-door nonsense could personify solved with just a touch of writing operating room by swapping in some different fine art resources. The Badlands example could have been fixed by making the fence twenty feet tall, stout, and covered in spikes. And maybe electrified. With that rather dispute, it starts to make sentience that IT would be easier to do the quest than to sidestep the wall. And the result would be that the story would be able to do its job and give us motivation for the stuff we're doing.

Because I'm interested: What's the well-nig absolute surgery asinine key-fetch you've ever had to liquidate a unfit?

PI Young is the guy rear this website, these ternion webcomics, and this program. Don't take his ranting too severely. He actually loves these games. He's just an insulting fan.

https://www.escapistmagazine.com/quest-for-the-sidequest/

Source: https://www.escapistmagazine.com/quest-for-the-sidequest/

Share this post